Hello dear
Welcome To Timoti's Seafood Shak
Welcome to Timoti's Seafood Shak, a delightful culinary gem located in Fernandina Beach, Florida. Our story is built on a passion for fresh, flavorful seafood and community connection. As part of the New American seafood scene, we pride ourselves on offering a diverse menu that caters to all diners, including vegan options and kid-friendly meals. Zealous about sustainability, we use compostable containers and plastic-free packaging. Our inviting outdoor seating encourages patrons to savor their meals among friends or family, soaking in the vibrant atmosphere. With quick service and hearty portions, each visit to Timoti's is a satisfying experience that keeps our guests coming back for more.
About
Timoti's Seafood Shak
Welcome to Timoti's Seafood Shak, a delightful gem nestled in Fernandina Beach, Florida. This charming eatery offers a fresh take on New American seafood, delivering a menu that caters to both seafood lovers and health-conscious diners alike. Located at 21 N 3rd St, Timoti's is not just a dining destination; it is an experience where quality meets sustainability.
Timoti's Seafood Shak shines with its commitment to offering takeout, delivery, and a welcoming atmosphere for outdoor seating. Whether you’re stopping by for a leisurely lunch with family or a casual dinner with friends, you will find a delightful array of options, including vegan choices and gluten-free meals. The atmosphere is casual yet lively, ideal for both groups and kids. You can enjoy your meal at community picnic benches, shaded under covered areas or soaking in the sunshine.
Our recent visit left us truly impressed by the variety and quality of the dishes. The reviews from regulars paint a vibrant picture of the culinary offerings. From Lori J.'s enthusiastic recommendation of the seafood stew and hearty gumbo, to the rave reviews about the Baja box with grilled shrimp from Sandra B., it is evident that every dish is crafted with care and flavor in mind. Jo H. praised the blackened drum fish, describing it as excellent, while Heidi C.'s gluten-free adventure yielded a scrumptious rice box, highlighting the eatery’s adaptability and thoughtful menu design.
One of the standout features is the generous portion sizing at wallet-friendly prices that keep guests returning for more. As Azaria A. captures perfectly, the meals feel light and fresh, making dining here a guilt-free indulgence. Customers particularly appreciate the happy hour specials and the inclusion of local ingredients that emphasize freshness.
Timoti’s Seafood Shak is not just about food; it’s about creating community. With offerings like catering, free Wi-Fi, and even a playground for children, it’s a place where families and friends can gather, bond, and share good times over incredibly tasty meals. Plus, the use of compostable containers and plastic-free packaging reflects a commitment to sustainability that resonates with today’s conscientious diners.
If you’re seeking an unforgettable seafood experience that serves up hearty flavors with a side of community spirit, look no further than Timoti’s Seafood Shak. Prepare to indulge in dishes that offer not just nourishment, but a celebration of Rusty’s coastal heritage.
For inquiries, reservations, and more, give them a call at (904) 310-6550. Don’t miss out on this local favorite—your taste buds will thank you!
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ Sorry I didn't get any photos, actually didn't have my phone on me. BUT, I recommend this lil place to everyone. Stop in and order your food and eat outside on community picnic benches. Covered areas and sunny spots too. Now the food - fantastic and the price will have you coming back for more. Meet a group of people here, service was quick, food was portioned well and priced better. Oh so yummy too. I had the seafood stew, okay gumbo (recommend ordering a side of rice), others had the rice bowl with fish on top (you would have thought a full entree with the portion), and those that had the lobster roll where surprised the order came with two. Everyone in the group was satisfied with the service and food. ”
“ The Baja box was really good. I got it with grilled shrimp but there was other options. Definitely recommend. ”
“ I had the fresh catch (drum fish, blackened) and it was excellent. My wife loved the chopped salad. ”
“ Food was amazing and fresh! Quick service and overall the meal felt light and healthy. Walked out full and happy. ”
“ A local gem! My partner and I ate here because Wicked Bao was closed and what a great unplanned meal it was! We needed to order gluten free since my partner is celiac, and it was easy at Timoti's. I had the rice box with shrimp which was a great mix of baby spinach, 1/2 avocado, slaw, rice and grilled shrimp - sooo good! My partner ordered the Baja box with blackened salmon which had beans instead of spinach and both were great. Prices were amazing and there was a playground for kiddos. One thing is we would have liked an option to get double protein for an additional fee - it could be that this is an unlisted option but I'd do that next time! ”
“ Great prices Many options No inside dining Pets welcome! Coke Zero! Fried Green Tomatoes were amazing Tuna Poke was great Sample wife's shrimp platter. The shrimp was good the fries were good the coleslaw need (way) more sauce And the hush puppies were just okay. ”
“ One of the few restaurants I was able to check out in Amelia island outside of the Ritz Carlton. My family with 2 young kids ended up staying at the resort mostly for our 3 night and didn't end up venturing out at all. I did pick up some take-out from Timoti's our first night in Amelia island and it was amazing. Very reasonable and great portions. I ordered 5-6 different items and it was less than $65. Highlights were the Tuna Poke bowl, the rice box and the fried fresh catch of the day. Everything was fresh and flavorful. Their poke sauce had a good combination of acid, salt and umami. I wanted to go back for lunch, but sadly didn't get a chance to. Until next time! ”
“ Wow, great food, and I would give it 10/10!! Everything I ordered was so fresh and tasteful. This place is a must!!! Came around lunchtime and the line was pretty long but once I ordered and sat down, it came pretty quickly. Must order the lobster roll and the shrimp tacos and basket!! What I ordered: - Shrimp basket blacked with fries, slaw, and hush puppies - Blacked Shrimp Tacos - Lobster Rolls: T's lobster salad served in two New England-style rolls - Fried Green Tomatoes ”
